This cited by count includes citations to the following articles in scholar. Regulation theory is an influential and significant strand of thought in social geography. Bob jessop 2012 bob jessop facss born 3 march 1946 is a british academic and writer who has published extensively on state theory and political economy. This chapter first considers some of the prominent proponents of competition state thesis, including philip cerny, bob jessop, and joachim hirsch. A critique of bob jessops application of biocybernetic. However, the state itself remains notoriously difficult to define, and the term is subject to a range of different interpretations. Debates about the role and nature of the state are at the heart of modern politics. Putting capitalist states in their place bob jessop on. My interest in theories of the state and state power dates back some twelve years or more and my interest in epistemological and methodological issues in theory construction is even. The strategicrelational view of the state wiley online library. This article is concerned with the past, present, and future of the state. Moreover, despite recurrent tendencies to reify them as standing outside and above society, the state and political system belong. The strategicrelational approach ohio state university. The legacy of nicos poulantzas in particular is singled out for its importance in laying the foundations for such an approach.
Marxist state theory, developed particularly by bob jessop. I have long been interested in theories of the capitalist state in general and the work of poulantzas in. Bob jessop facss born 3 march 1946 is a british academic and writer who has published extensively on state theory and political economy. It then moves on to trace the origins of the state and state building, and discuss karl marxs various approaches to the state. Here i deal with the whole range of explicitly marxist theories concerned with the logical derivation of the form andor functions of the capitalist state. Bob jessop state theory putting the capitalist state in its. Putting the capitalist state in its place jessop, bob on. A read is counted each time someone views a publication summary such as the title, abstract, and list of authors, clicks on a figure, or views or downloads the fulltext. The political scene and the politics of representation. Moreover, although his project was as much political. The competition state european university institute. This volume develops a novel approach to state theory. One such approach is the socalled staatsableitungdebatte or state derivation debate.
His knowledge of and contribution to marxist political economy has been comprehensive and he is a prolific writer whose work. From localities via the spatial turn to spatiotemporal fixes. Bob jessop march 27, 2014 this online version is the precopyedited, preprint version. His contribution has focused on the reformulation of state theory. Periodizing class struggle and the state in the eighteenth brumaire bob jessop the eighteenth brumaire of louis bonaparte has a key place in debates over marxs theory of the state and his account of political representation. Pdf states, state power, and state theory in critical.
In developing these issues, bob jessop both builds on and goes well beyond the view presented in his earlier books, the capitalist state 1982 and nicos poulantzas 1985. The result is a highly original statement that should stimulate much debate. Putting capitalist states in their place sage journals. The state and state power are hypercomplex and changeable phenomena and no single theory or theoretical perspective can fully capture and explain their structural and strategic dynamic. Bob jessop is distinguished professor of sociology at lancaster university, united kingdom. The strategicrelational view of the state duncan kelly, 1999. Past, present, future is a masterful piece of work with a command over. State power by bob jessop overdrive rakuten overdrive. In developing these issues, bob jessop both builds on and goeswell beyond the view presented in his earlier books, the capitalist state 1982 and nicos poulantzas 1985. A case is made for cultural political economy cpe by exploring the constitutive role of semiosis in economic and political activities, economic and political institutions, and social order more g. Whether youve loved the book or not, if you give your honest and detailed thoughts then people will find new books that are right for them. Nov 01, 1990 this volume develops a novel approach to state theory. This reformulation aims at a conceptualisation of an intermediate concept of state. It is in this context that bob jessops book provides an insightful overview of the state and state theory, and adds his own contribution to this.
Other readers will always be interested in your opinion of the books youve read. There has been a major renewal of marxist work on state theory in the last thirty years. Bob jessop state theory putting the capitalist state in. He lucidly guides readers through all the major accounts of the state, and examines competing efforts to relate the state to other features of social organization. In this book, distinguished state theorist bob jessop provides a critical introduction to the state as both a concept and a reality. The state has obvious interests in how its territory is populated and in the quantity and quality of its population.
Marxist state theory retrieved, i advanced the viewa view i stand by to this daythat nicos poulantzass theory developed over the all too brief span of his career in such a way that we can almost read in his successive writings the history of twentiethcentury marxist state theory in miniature, orin petto. Nicos poulantzas marxist theory and political strategy preface the idea for this book first took shape in early 1979 and it has been some five years in coming to fruition. Critical semiotic analysis and cultural political economy. State theorists have usually attempted to theorize the state but this is a misleading focus that risks treating the state as a simple instrument or machine, a reified apparatus that is primarily a source of constraint on political action, or a more or less rational subject that exercises power.
However, it has been deemed that no single theory can completely capture and explain its complexities. It then establishes a continuum of neoliberalism ranging from a project for radical system transformation from state socialism to market capitalism, through a basic regime shift within capitalism, to more limited policy adjustments intended to maintain another type of accumulation regime and its mode of regulation. This book has been an unconscionably long time in the making. Bob jessop regulation theory, post fordism and the state. This has been prompted by the crisis of the national state and its typical forms of intervention in the 1970s.
According to bob jessop, the competition state is the naturally. If you were to ask any adult to choose between sex or masturbating alone, a large majority of them would confidently select the former. Thats because there is a certain stigma surrounding both forms of sexual pleasure that has led most of us to believe that sex is inherently better than masturbating. This paper seeks to highlight the main elements of the strategicrelational approach to marxist state theory, developed particularly by bob jessop. It is extraordinarily well written and despite its theoretical complexity, jessop is careful to avoid the flight into jargon and the opacity so often associated with marxist thought. Struggle and the state in the eighteenth brumaire bob jessop the eighteenth brumaire of louis bonaparte has a key place in debates over marxs theory of the state and his account of political representation. It examines and extends the work of the eponymous greek legal and political theorist, political economist, and communist intellectual, nicos poulantzas, who radically transformed marxist state theory, made major contributions to the critique of political economy for the era of atlantic. Pdf states, state power, and state theory researchgate. February 16, 2017 bob jessop, the state, part i discussion agenda 1. It then moves on to trace the origins of the state and statebuilding, and discuss karl marxs various approaches to the state.
Putting the capitalist state in its place bob jessop polity press, 1991, pages 426, pdf. For some critics, this text provides evidence for two marxian theories of the state. Whereas the welfare state domesticated capitalism, the competition state vies for capital. This was also when i got interested in crossborder regions and other aspects of economic and political rescaling including, along with mainstream social science, the issue of the nature, extent, and significance of globalization jessop 1995, 1999, 2002. Bob jessop is undoubtedly one of the major theorists working within the british tradition of regulation theory. He is currently distinguished professor of sociology at the university of lancaster. Three components in general state theory identify formal aspects of state. This comprises the subject matter of the third chapter. More than a reply to werner bonefeld capital and class 34, pp. Journal of political ecology university of arizona. He has worked for many years on theories of the state and state.
701 273 1534 1228 1033 777 1190 513 563 1475 343 1093 156 879 1589 523 914 459 1086 896 650 459 1399 1021 1145 475 209 345 1102 889 166 764